INTEREST GROUPS

Template

20230114-292-2 pp.jpg

The Great Mirehaven Beverage Debate

story by Paul Tanenbaum and photos by Natalie Tanenbaum

00000000076081f8b849ea022988cf21.png

The contenders, Beer, Spirits, and Wine

AI generated

October 20, 2026. Tuesday, the Mirehaven Discussion and Debate Group (MDDG) hosted an engaging, lively, and educational event in the Manzano Room that everyone in attendance enjoyed. The Wine, Beer and Spirits Debate donated all money raised to Mirehaven Gives Back (MGB).

20261020181012.png

Larry Yatsko, Chuck Webster, and Jeff Milligan

Chris Kovalesky (MDDG) had the honor of moderating the debate. Larry Yatsko (Wine Interest Group leader) represented wine; Chuck Webster (beer aficionado) represented beer; and Jeff Milligan (Managing Partner, Unhinged Brewing and Distilling) represented spirits. Each debater had five minutes to discuss the merits and history of their beverage. A lively half-hour audience question-and-answer session followed, mixing serious discussion with humor. Each debater then offered brief closing remarks, often combining humor with verbal and pictorial presentations.

The audience of more than 35 heard spirited arguments for all three beverages. Wine was praised for its diversity, food pairings, ability to improve with age, and history stretching back at least 8,000 years. Spirits—limited to whiskey for this debate—were presented as an American icon, with a history dating to the 1600s, great cocktail potential, and a hearty endorsement from Doc Holliday. Beer, its advocate argued, was slightly better than wine or spirits: it tolerates ignorance, is readily available, comes in nonalcoholic varieties, and has a history going back at least 12,000 years.

To choose the winner, audience members voted with their money. Wine, beer, and spirits each had a separate voting jar, and attendees deposited money into the jar for their favorite throughout the debate, especially at the end. Wine won with $174, followed by spirits with $117 and beer with $89.

20261020180303.png

Larry Yatsko, Chuck Webster, and Jeff Mulligan

20261020175944.png

Karin Garcia, Jeff Mulligan, Chris Kovalesky, Larry Yatsko, Deb Karasik, Linda Lovin, Chuck Webster

The grand total of $380 was donated to MGB, a start on next year’s fundraising.

Glenn Gaylord, MGB; Chris Kovalesky, MDDGG; Gary Armstrong, MGB.jpg

Glenn Gaylord, MGB; Chris Kovalesky, MDDGG; Gary Armstrong, MGB